Cosmeceuticals
Cosmeceuticals Market by Product Type (Hair Care, Lip Care, Skin Care), Material Type (Multifunctional or Synthetic, Natural), Active Ingredients, Distribution Channel - Global Forecast 2024-2030
360iResearch Analyst
SPEAK TO ANALYST? OR FACE-TO-FACE MEETING?
Want to know more about the cosmeceuticals market or any specific requirement? Ketan helps you find what you're looking for.
DOWNLOAD A FREE PDF
This free PDF includes market data points, ranging from trend analysis to market estimates & forecasts. See for yourself.

[188 Pages Report] The Cosmeceuticals Market size was estimated at USD 81.12 billion in 2023 and expected to reach USD 87.13 billion in 2024, at a CAGR 7.69% to reach USD 136.29 billion by 2030.

Cosmeceuticals refer to cosmetic products composed of active ingredients that are known to have cosmetic benefits and therapeutic effects capable of changing skin function and structure. Cosmeceuticals have diverse applications in both professional settings (such as dermatology clinics, spas, and beauty salons) and at-home use by consumers. The end-users for these products span different age groups and demographics seeking improved skin health, appearance enhancement, or treatment of specific skin conditions such as acne or hyperpigmentation. Cosmeceuticals products can include anti-aging creams and serums, advanced skin cleansers, skin tightening products, moisturizers, and sun protection creams, among others. Increasing knowledge about skincare ingredients and their benefits among consumers has led to a higher demand for cosmeceutical products offering targeted solutions. An increasing preference for natural and eco-friendly alternatives is driving demand for cosmeceutical formulations with plant-based or sustainable ingredients, such as botanical extracts or probiotics. However, a lack of awareness about available cosmeceutical products reduces the purchase of cosmeceutical products. Furthermore, with no globally unified regulatory structure governing cosmeceuticals, there is a risk of inconsistent quality or misleading claims associated with some products. However, major players are constantly investing efforts to raise brand awareness through celebrity endorsements and social media marketing. Advancements in ingredient research have resulted in novel active ingredients with enhanced efficacy or new mechanisms of action, fueling the product pipeline and adoption of cosmeceuticals.

Regional Insights

The Americas has long been at the forefront of innovation in cosmeceutical development and consumption. North America is home to some of the world's leading cosmetic companies that invest heavily in the research and development of technologically advanced cosmeceutical products. As a result, consumers in this region have access to a wide range of high-quality cosmeceutical offerings targeted at various age groups and specific needs like anti-aging or skin brightening treatments. Asia's rising disposable income levels and increasing awareness about skincare routines have propelled Asian countries, including South Korea, Japan, China, and India, into becoming major players in the global cosmeceutical arena. The Asian market is characterized by its rapid shift towards natural and organic ingredients, which cater to local preferences for traditional medicine-based beauty practices. Asian manufacturers are known for their cutting-edge innovation, which emphasizes unique formulations based on advanced science-backed technologies such as stem cell research or nanotechnology. The European cosmeceuticals market is driven by a consumer base that values luxury and high-quality products. European countries of France, Italy, Germany, and the United Kingdom have long-standing traditions in cosmetic production and consumption. Esteemed brands in the region are synonymous with premium quality skincare offerings that leverage advanced scientific research to deliver high-performance results tailored to cater to sophisticated European tastes.

Cosmeceuticals Market
To learn more about this report, request a free PDF copy
Market Dynamics

The market dynamics represent an ever-changing landscape of the Cosmeceuticals Market by providing actionable insights into factors, including supply and demand levels. Accounting for these factors helps design strategies, make investments, and formulate developments to capitalize on future opportunities. In addition, these factors assist in avoiding potential pitfalls related to political, geographical, technical, social, and economic conditions, highlighting consumer behaviors and influencing manufacturing costs and purchasing decisions.

  • Market Drivers
    • Growing understanding of beauty and wellness trends worldwide
    • Rising environmental consciousness and popularity of bio-based cosmeceutical products
    • Availability of a diverse range of cosmeceutical products through online channels
  • Market Restraints
    • Surging incidences of product recalls due to quality concerns
  • Market Opportunities
    • Advent of personalized and customized skincare solutions with digital analytics
    • Research activities supporting the development of new cosmeceutical formulations
  • Market Challenges
    • Strict regulations and standards surrounding cosmaceutical production and marketing
Market Segmentation Analysis
  • Products: Utilization of cosmeceuticals to target the rising number of skin issues

    Hair care cosmeceuticals target diverse concerns such as hair loss, scalp health, and damage repair. Various serums, conditioners, oils, and pharmaceutical interventions are available as topical treatments to target hair loss and stimulate hair growth. Products in this category aim to reduce hair loss and promote hair strength by targeting common causes such as breakage, dryness, and dandruff. Scalp repair solutions target issues such as itchiness and flaking. Lip scrub, lip balm, and lip polishing oil are cosmeceutical products used to provide optimum lip care by preventing dryness, chapping, and cracking of lips. Skincare cosmeceuticals address concerns such as anti-aging, skin brightening, acne management, sun protection, and hydration. Anti-acne products aim to treat existing acne breakouts while preventing future ones by controlling sebum production and reducing inflammation. Anti-aging products work to reduce visible signs of aging, such as wrinkles, fine lines, and age spots. Anti-stress soothes the skin, while moisturizers provide hydration for the skin. Products in this category help in lightening sun-induced tans and even out the skin tone by inhibiting melanin production. Skin whitening products target hyperpigmentation issues such as dark spots or uneven skin tone. Advanced skin cleansers and scar gels & creams are used to improve overall skin appearance. Skin tightening products provide a youthful appearance to the skin, while sun protection products protect the skin against environmental factors such as harmful ultraviolet light. Anti-cellulite creams and body slimming creams target certain fat-storing parts of the body, helping reduce weight.

  • Material: Growing preference of consumers for natural materials owing to concerns about sustainability

    Multifunctional materials in cosmeceuticals often combine the benefits of multiple ingredients to create innovative products that address various skin concerns. These materials offer advantages such as increased stability, improved formulation efficacy, and easier handling for manufacturers. Natural ingredients have gained popularity among consumers seeking more environmentally friendly alternatives without compromising effectiveness. Natural materials are derived from plant extracts, essential oils, and other biodegradable sources and often provide similar benefits as synthetic counterparts but with a reduced ecological footprint.

  • Active Ingredients: Exponential use of antioxidants as they provide protection against environmental stressors

    Antioxidants are essential for neutralizing free radicals that can cause premature aging and damage to the skin. Some common antioxidants used in cosmeceuticals include Vitamin C, Vitamin E, and resveratrol. Botanicals are plant-derived ingredients known for their soothing and nurturing properties. Widely used botanical ingredients include aloe vera, chamomile extract, green tea extract, and witch hazel. Exfoliants are crucial for removing dead skin cells to reveal smoother, more radiant skin beneath them. There are two primary types of exfoliants: physical exfoliants, which consist of microbeads and crushed shells, and chemical exfoliants, such as alpha-hydroxy acids (AHAs) and beta-hydroxy acids (BHAs). Peptides and proteins play a vital role in enhancing skin elasticity and promoting collagen synthesis. Retinoids are derivatives of Vitamin A that help stimulate cellular turnover, leading to smoother skin texture, reduced fine lines, and improved pigmentation issues.

  • Distribution Channel: Access to unique products with detailed reviews through online distribution channel

    Beauty salons constitute a major distribution channel for cosmeceuticals, as they provide consumers with professional consultation services and personalized product recommendations based on individual skin types and concerns. Online retailing has emerged as a dominant distribution channel due to increased consumer convenience and access to a wider range of products at competitive prices. Additionally, e-commerce platforms offer detailed product information and customer reviews that guide consumers in making informed purchasing decisions. Pharmacy and drug stores are another popular distribution channel for cosmeceuticals since they offer customers easy access to professional advice from pharmacists or store associates. Specialty stores focus on offering niche and premium cosmeceutical products from brands that cater specifically to target consumer segments. Beauty salons are ideal for those seeking personalized consultation services and expert advice, while online retailing offers convenience, competitive prices, and wider product assortments. Pharmacy and drug stores provide easy access to professional advice along with reputable brands for customers who prioritize safety and efficacy.

Market Disruption Analysis

The market disruption analysis delves into the core elements associated with market-influencing changes, including breakthrough technological advancements that introduce novel features, integration capabilities, regulatory shifts that could drive or restrain market growth, and the emergence of innovative market players challenging traditional paradigms. This analysis facilitates a competitive advantage by preparing players in the Cosmeceuticals Market to pre-emptively adapt to these market-influencing changes, enhances risk management by early identification of threats, informs calculated investment decisions, and drives innovation toward areas with the highest demand in the Cosmeceuticals Market.

Porter’s Five Forces Analysis

The porter's five forces analysis offers a simple and powerful tool for understanding, identifying, and analyzing the position, situation, and power of the businesses in the Cosmeceuticals Market. This model is helpful for companies to understand the strength of their current competitive position and the position they are considering repositioning into. With a clear understanding of where power lies, businesses can take advantage of a situation of strength, improve weaknesses, and avoid taking wrong steps. The tool identifies whether new products, services, or companies have the potential to be profitable. In addition, it can be very informative when used to understand the balance of power in exceptional use cases.

Value Chain & Critical Path Analysis

The value chain of the Cosmeceuticals Market encompasses all intermediate value addition activities, including raw materials used, product inception, and final delivery, aiding in identifying competitive advantages and improvement areas. Critical path analysis of the <> market identifies task sequences crucial for timely project completion, aiding resource allocation and bottleneck identification. Value chain and critical path analysis methods optimize efficiency, improve quality, enhance competitiveness, and increase profitability. Value chain analysis targets production inefficiencies, and critical path analysis ensures project timeliness. These analyses facilitate businesses in making informed decisions, responding to market demands swiftly, and achieving sustainable growth by optimizing operations and maximizing resource utilization.

Pricing Analysis

The pricing analysis comprehensively evaluates how a product or service is priced within the Cosmeceuticals Market. This evaluation encompasses various factors that impact the price of a product, including production costs, competition, demand, customer value perception, and changing margins. An essential aspect of this analysis is understanding price elasticity, which measures how sensitive the market for a product is to its price change. It provides insight into competitive pricing strategies, enabling businesses to position their products advantageously in the Cosmeceuticals Market.

Technology Analysis

The technology analysis involves evaluating the current and emerging technologies relevant to a specific industry or market. This analysis includes breakthrough trends across the value chain that directly define the future course of long-term profitability and overall advancement in the Cosmeceuticals Market.

Patent Analysis

The patent analysis involves evaluating patent filing trends, assessing patent ownership, analyzing the legal status and compliance, and collecting competitive intelligence from patents within the Cosmeceuticals Market and its parent industry. Analyzing the ownership of patents, assessing their legal status, and interpreting the patents to gather insights into competitors' technology strategies assist businesses in strategizing and optimizing product positioning and investment decisions.

Trade Analysis

The trade analysis of the Cosmeceuticals Market explores the complex interplay of import and export activities, emphasizing the critical role played by key trading nations. This analysis identifies geographical discrepancies in trade flows, offering a deep insight into regional disparities to identify geographic areas suitable for market expansion. A detailed analysis of the regulatory landscape focuses on tariffs, taxes, and customs procedures that significantly determine international trade flows. This analysis is crucial for understanding the overarching legal framework that businesses must navigate.

Regulatory Framework Analysis

The regulatory framework analysis for the Cosmeceuticals Market is essential for ensuring legal compliance, managing risks, shaping business strategies, fostering innovation, protecting consumers, accessing markets, maintaining reputation, and managing stakeholder relations. Regulatory frameworks shape business strategies and expansion initiatives, guiding informed decision-making processes. Furthermore, this analysis uncovers avenues for innovation within existing regulations or by advocating for regulatory changes to foster innovation.

We at Seppic S.A. faced significant challenges in navigating the evolving landscape of bio-based cosmeceutical products. The Cosmeceuticals Market Research Report by 360iResearch provided invaluable insights and strategies, particularly in understanding rising environmental consciousness among consumers. By leveraging the report's in-depth analysis, we successfully adapted our product offerings to meet market demand, resulting in a noticeable increase in customer satisfaction and sales. We highly commend 360iResearch for their thorough and impactful research.
Seppic S.A.
To learn more about this report, request a free PDF copy
FPNV Positioning Matrix

The FPNV positioning matrix is essential in evaluating the market positioning of the vendors in the Cosmeceuticals Market. This matrix offers a comprehensive assessment of vendors, examining critical metrics related to business strategy and product satisfaction. This in-depth assessment empowers users to make well-informed decisions aligned with their requirements. Based on the evaluation, the vendors are then categorized into four distinct quadrants representing varying levels of success, namely Forefront (F), Pathfinder (P), Niche (N), or Vital (V).

Market Share Analysis

The market share analysis is a comprehensive tool that provides an insightful and in-depth assessment of the current state of vendors in the Cosmeceuticals Market. By meticulously comparing and analyzing vendor contributions, companies are offered a greater understanding of their performance and the challenges they face when competing for market share. These contributions include overall revenue, customer base, and other vital metrics. Additionally, this analysis provides valuable insights into the competitive nature of the sector, including factors such as accumulation, fragmentation dominance, and amalgamation traits observed over the base year period studied. With these illustrative details, vendors can make more informed decisions and devise effective strategies to gain a competitive edge in the market.

Recent Developments
  • No7 Launched Cosmeceuticals Range

    No7 launched its Derm Solutions range of cosmeceutical products. This nine-product line was meticulously developed with the valuable input of dermatologists to target and address various skin concerns effectively. The range comprises five essential products that work harmoniously to maintain the skin's natural barrier and promote healthy, balanced skin within four weeks. [Published On: 2023-09-29]

  • K-beauty’s Cosmecca to Partner with Vytrus Biotech on Cosmetic Ingredients Research

    Cosmecca Korea Co., a K-beauty manufacturer, partnered with Vytrus Biotech, a Spanish cosmetic ingredient firm. This partnership aims to research and develop cosmetic ingredients using plant stem cell technology. Through this partnership, Vytrus Biotech can introduce cutting-edge European technology to the Korean market while benefiting from Cosmecca's valuable insights into K-beauty trends. [Published On: 2023-08-03]

  • L'Oréal Acquires Aesop for $2.5 Billion

    L'Oréal, a cosmetics company, acquired Aesop, an Australian luxury cosmetics brand, for a substantial amount of USD 2.52 billion. With this acquisition, L'Oréal intends to expand Aesop's presence in the Chinese market and invest in its travel retail operations. This strategic move enables L'Oréal to strengthen its position in the cosmetics industry and tap into Aesop's brand reputation and offerings. [Published On: 2023-04-04]

Strategy Analysis & Recommendation

The strategic analysis is essential for organizations seeking a solid foothold in the global marketplace. Companies are better positioned to make informed decisions that align with their long-term aspirations by thoroughly evaluating their current standing in the Cosmeceuticals Market. This critical assessment involves a thorough analysis of the organization’s resources, capabilities, and overall performance to identify its core strengths and areas for improvement.

Before leveraging the Cosmeceuticals Market Research Report by 360iResearch, we struggled with staying ahead in the competitive market of cosmeceutical formulations. The invaluable insights and actionable strategies provided by the report transformed our approach. We discovered emerging trends, competitors' strategies, and consumer preferences which guided our R&D efforts. Specifically, the report's granular analysis on ingredient innovation led to successful product launches that resonated with our target audience. Our overall satisfaction is immense, as the report significantly improved our development processes and market positioning.
HSA Cosmetics SpA
To learn more about this report, request a free PDF copy
Key Company Profiles

The report delves into recent significant developments in the Cosmeceuticals Market, highlighting leading vendors and their innovative profiles. These include Seppic S.A., HSA Cosmetics SpA, Vitabiotics Ltd., Functionalab, Bosley Professional Strength Co. Ltd., Uniliver PLC, BeBodywise, GNC Holdings, Inc., Shiseido Company, Limited, KORA Organics by Miranda Kerr Pty Ltd., Herbalife Nutrition Ltd., Bestvite, Croda International PLC, Amway Corporation, Huatai Biopharm Inc., L'Oréal S.A., VEGAMOUR, INC., BASF SE, D-Lab Nutricosmetics, Gelita AG, Johnson & Johnson Services, Inc., HUM Nutrition Inc., Avon Products, Inc, Estée Lauder Companies Inc., Procter & Gamble Company, Industrial Farmacéutica Cantabria, SA, Grupo Cantabria Labs, Sabinsa Corporation, Biocyte SAS, Hale Cosmeceuticals Inc, Beiersdorf AG, Blackmores Limited, and Allergan Aesthetics by AbbVie Inc..

Cosmeceuticals Market - Global Forecast 2024-2030
To learn more about this report, request a free PDF copy
Market Segmentation & Coverage

This research report categorizes the Cosmeceuticals Market to forecast the revenues and analyze trends in each of the following sub-markets:

  • Product Type
    • Hair Care
      • Anti-Dandruff Solutions
      • Hair Fall Solutions
      • Hair Growth Products
      • Scalp Repair
    • Lip Care
    • Skin Care
      • Advanced Skin Cleansers
      • Anti-Acne
      • Anti-Aging Creams & Serums
      • Anti-Cellulite
      • Anti-Wrinkles
      • Body Slimming Creams
      • Moisturizers
      • Scar Gels & Creams
      • Skin Tightening Products
      • Skin Whitening
      • Sun Protection
  • Material Type
    • Multifunctional or Synthetic
    • Natural
  • Active Ingredients
    • Antioxidants
    • Botanicals
    • Exfoliants
    • Peptides & Protiens
    • Retinoids
  • Distribution Channel
    • Beauty Salons
    • Online Retailing
    • Pharmacy & Drug Stores
    • Specialty Stores

  • Region
    • Americas
      • Argentina
      • Brazil
      • Canada
      • Mexico
      • United States
        • California
        • Florida
        • Illinois
        • New York
        • Ohio
        • Pennsylvania
        • Texas
    • Asia-Pacific
      • Australia
      • China
      • India
      • Indonesia
      • Japan
      • Malaysia
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • South Korea
      • Taiwan
      • Thailand
      • Vietnam
    • Europe, Middle East & Africa
      • Denmark
      • Egypt
      • Finland
      • France
      • Germany
      • Israel
      • Italy
      • Netherlands
      • Nigeria
      • Norway
      • Poland
      • Qatar
      • Russia
      • Saudi Arabia
      • South Africa
      • Spain
      • Sweden
      • Switzerland
      • Turkey
      • United Arab Emirates
      • United Kingdom

Before discovering the Cosmeceuticals Market Research Report by 360iResearch, we were grappling with market ambiguity and lacked precise direction for our product strategies. The advent of personalized and customized skincare solutions with digital analytics highlighted in the report provided us with invaluable insights and actionable strategies. Not only did we understand current market dynamics better, but we also tailored our product offerings to meet specific consumer needs more effectively. For instance, the segment analyses and trend forecasts enabled us to launch a new skincare line, which saw a 25% increase in customer engagement. We're immensely satisfied with how this report has positively impacted our operations and driven success within our organization.
Vitabiotics Ltd.
To learn more about this report, request a free PDF copy
This research report offers invaluable insights into various crucial aspects of the Cosmeceuticals Market:

  1. Market Penetration: This section thoroughly overviews the current market landscape, incorporating detailed data from key industry players.
  2. Market Development: The report examines potential growth prospects in emerging markets and assesses expansion opportunities in mature segments.
  3. Market Diversification: This includes detailed information on recent product launches, untapped geographic regions, recent industry developments, and strategic investments.
  4. Competitive Assessment & Intelligence: An in-depth analysis of the competitive landscape is conducted, covering market share, strategic approaches, product range, certifications, regulatory approvals, patent analysis, technology developments, and advancements in the manufacturing capabilities of leading market players.
  5. Product Development & Innovation: This section offers insights into upcoming technologies, research and development efforts, and notable advancements in product innovation.

Additionally, the report addresses key questions to assist stakeholders in making informed decisions:

  1. What is the current market size and projected growth?
  2. Which products, segments, applications, and regions offer promising investment opportunities?
  3. What are the prevailing technology trends and regulatory frameworks?
  4. What is the market share and positioning of the leading vendors?
  5. What revenue sources and strategic opportunities do vendors in the market consider when deciding to enter or exit?

Table of Contents
  1. Preface
  2. Research Methodology
  3. Executive Summary
  4. Market Overview
  5. Market Insights
  6. Cosmeceuticals Market, by Product Type
  7. Cosmeceuticals Market, by Material Type
  8. Cosmeceuticals Market, by Active Ingredients
  9. Cosmeceuticals Market, by Distribution Channel
  10. Americas Cosmeceuticals Market
  11. Asia-Pacific Cosmeceuticals Market
  12. Europe, Middle East & Africa Cosmeceuticals Market
  13. Competitive Landscape
  14. Competitive Portfolio
  15. List of Figures [Total: 24]
  16. List of Tables [Total: 578]
  17. List of Companies Mentioned [Total: 33]
Understanding the Benefits of Cosmeceuticals in a Bio-Based World
November 1, 2023
BLOG
Understanding the Benefits of Cosmeceuticals in a Bio-Based World
The world of beauty has come a long way in the past couple of years, with newer technologies and formulations taking over the traditional cosmetic industry. The inception of cosmeceuticals has been one of the most significant advancements in the beauty and skincare world. This blog post talks about what cosmeceuticals are, their benefits, and why bio-based cosmeceuticals are becoming so popular.

What are Cosmeceuticals?

Cosmeceuticals are a combination of cosmetics and pharmaceuticals. These products contain active ingredients that not only enhance the appearance of the skin but also target deeper skin concerns such as pigmentation, aging, and acne. They differ from traditional cosmetics due to the concentration of active ingredients and the strength of their effects. Most cosmeceuticals are formulated with active plant-based ingredients to enhance the overall health of the skin, unlike synthetic chemicals that may cause adverse reactions to the skin.

Benefits of Cosmeceuticals:

Cosmeceuticals offer plenty of benefits over traditional skincare products. One of the most crucial advantages is that they target specific skin issues. These products contain active ingredients that penetrate deeper into the skin, thereby treating skin concerns from the root level. They not only work to improve the texture of the skin but also work to improve moisture retention levels, prevent fine lines and wrinkles, and fight against environmental stressors. Most cosmeceuticals also contain antioxidants that protect the skin from free radicals, making them a popular anti-aging product in the market.

Bio-Based Cosmeceuticals:

Bio-based cosmeceuticals use natural ingredients from plants and animals, such as algae, seaweed, snail extract, and honey, to name a few. These skin-beneficial ingredients work naturally with the skin without adding potentially harmful chemicals to the skin. Bio-based products are eco-friendly and sustainable, making them the best pick for environmentally conscious consumers. They are free from genetic modification, synthetic hormones, and growth factors commonly used in synthetic formulations, making them more likely to be compatible with all skin types.

Why Bio-Based Cosmeceuticals Are Rising in Popularity:

Bio-based cosmeceuticals are gaining immense popularity among consumers for their all-natural, skin-friendly, and environmentally conscious appeal. With increasing awareness about the side-effects of synthetic ingredients on the skin and the environment, most consumers now seek and prefer products made from natural ingredients that are eco-friendly. With intensive research, bio-based cosmeceuticals now provide skincare solutions that are as effective as their synthetic counterparts. Many beauty and skincare brands are now using natural ingredients as active components in cosmeceuticals to cater to customers who prefer natural beauty products.

Cosmeceuticals are a new generation of skincare products that work to improve the health of the skin while targeting specific skin concerns with active ingredients. Bio-based cosmeceuticals use natural skin-beneficial ingredients to enhance the skin's health while preserving and protecting the environment. As more consumers become conscious of environmental preservation, bio-based cosmeceuticals are a perfect fit for environmentally conscious consumers.

Frequently Asked Questions
  1. How big is the Cosmeceuticals Market?
    Ans. The Global Cosmeceuticals Market size was estimated at USD 81.12 billion in 2023 and expected to reach USD 87.13 billion in 2024.
  2. What is the Cosmeceuticals Market growth?
    Ans. The Global Cosmeceuticals Market to grow USD 136.29 billion by 2030, at a CAGR of 7.69%
  3. When do I get the report?
    Ans. Most reports are fulfilled immediately. In some cases, it could take up to 2 business days.
  4. In what format does this report get delivered to me?
    Ans. We will send you an email with login credentials to access the report. You will also be able to download the pdf and excel.
  5. How long has 360iResearch been around?
    Ans. We are approaching our 7th anniversary in 2024!
  6. What if I have a question about your reports?
    Ans. Call us, email us, or chat with us! We encourage your questions and feedback. We have a research concierge team available and included in every purchase to help our customers find the research they need-when they need it.
  7. Can I share this report with my team?
    Ans. Absolutely yes, with the purchase of additional user licenses.
  8. Can I use your research in my presentation?
    Ans. Absolutely yes, so long as the 360iResearch cited correctly.